How to make old-fashioned collared salmon — the forgotten technique worth reviving
Collared salmon is a technique that has largely disappeared from the home kitchen, and Big Daddy thinks that’s a shame. Rolling the salmon before poaching isn’t a gimmick — it creates a uniform log that cooks evenly throughout, holds its shape beautifully on the plate, and makes an impressive presentation for almost no extra effort. The vinegar-and-bay-leaf poaching liquid sounds unusual but produces something remarkably clean and bright. And the preservation trick at the end — boiling the liquor and pouring it back over the cold fish — means this recipe actually gets better the next day. That’s rare.
Old-Fashioned Collared Salmon Poached in Vinegar and Bay Leaves
Ingredients
Method
- Instructions
- Split the fish. Scale, bone, and wash it thoroughly. Pat dry.
- Rub the seasoning of salt, pounded mace, and pepper generously into the fish — inside and out.
- Roll the fish up tightly and bind firmly with kitchen twine to hold the shape.
- Place the rolled fish in a kettle. Cover with the vinegar and water mixture (1 part vinegar to 3 parts water).
- Add the bay leaves, a good seasoning of salt, and whole peppercorns to the liquid.
- Bring to a gentle simmer. Do not remove the lid during cooking. Simmer approximately 45 minutes or slightly more.
- Serve with melted butter or anchovy sauce.
Why This Works
Rolling and binding the salmon before poaching is the technique that makes this dish — it creates an even, uniform log that cooks consistently throughout without any thin edges overcooking while the center stays raw. The vinegar in the poaching liquid does two things: it firms the protein structure slightly, helping the roll hold its shape, and it adds a subtle brightness that works against the richness of the fish. Keeping the lid on throughout is critical — it traps steam and creates a gentle, humid environment that prevents the surface from drying out. The bay leaves and mace perfume the flesh from the outside in.
What to Serve With This
Collared salmon is elegant enough to serve as a centerpiece dish. Accompany it with a light cucumber salad dressed in white wine vinegar and dill, thin-sliced brown bread and butter, and boiled waxy potatoes. Anchovy sauce is the traditional choice and the more assertive pairing — melted butter is softer and lets the salmon speak. A chilled dry Chablis or Muscadet is the ideal wine match.
Make It Your Own
Mace can be replaced with a pinch of freshly grated nutmeg if that’s what you have. For a more herbal profile, tuck a few sprigs of fresh dill or tarragon inside the roll before binding. The 1:3 vinegar-to-water ratio is a baseline — go 1:4 if you want a more delicate poaching flavor, or add a splash of dry white wine to the liquid for complexity. This recipe also works beautifully with a large piece of arctic char or steelhead trout in place of salmon.
Storage & Leftovers
This is one of the few salmon preparations that genuinely preserves well. After cooking, boil the strained poaching liquor with an additional splash of vinegar, let cool, and pour over the cold collared salmon. Covered and refrigerated, it will keep for 4–5 days and actually improves in flavor as it sits. Serve cold directly from the fridge — no reheating needed.
You Might Also Love
If you loved this recipe, try these next:
Want more Big Daddy recipes? Grab your free cookbook
